Inspired by Margarita, my Puerto Rican con-worker (at my non-jello day job), and her annual holiday offering of Coquito, Puerto Rico’s version of eggnog, I made a Coquito Jello for this year’s office holiday party. Loaded to the gills with rum (at least the way Margarita makes it) it has a creamy base of coconut milk and sweetened condensed milk and is spiced with cinnamon, nutmeg, and allspice. Intoxicatingly delicious! See the recipe below and have a Merry Christmas!
3 tablespoons (3 envelopes) of unflavored gelatin powder
2 cups coconut milk
1 ½ cups sweetened condensed milk
1/2 cup water
1 teaspoon vanilla extract
1/4 teaspoon cinnamon
1/8 teaspoon allspice
1/8 teaspoon nutmeg
3/4 cup white rum
In a saucepan, sprinkle gelatin evenly over the coconut milk and allow the gelatin to absorb the coconut milk for 2 minutes. Whisk gelatin into the coconut milk while bringing it to a boil, careful not to let it boil over. Remove from heat and transfer to a large bowl. Whisk in the sweetened condensed milk and water until the mixture is smooth. Stir in the spices and vanilla. Allow to cool to room temperature and then stir in the rum. Refrigerate until it cools and begins to thicken. Stir again to evenly distribute any spices that may have settled to the top or bottom and then gently spoon into a 4 to 5 cup mold. Refrigerate overnight. Unmold and serve.
The Jello Mold Mistress 
Coconut milk, rum, jello how could you go wrong?
I admit to a bit of tweaking – less sweetened condensed milk and more rum. This was a huge hit! Could be my new pre-xmas jello treat! Many thanks.
I made this for our family Christmas dinner and it was wonderful, so a week later, we made it again as jell-o shots for a New Year’s Eve party. Love it!
I thought this recipient would be amazing for an upcoming party Jell-O shots, and I was right!!! I used a Wilton snowflake silicone mold and it made enough for 36 snowflakes. Taste amazing and I can’t wait to share with my guests next week!
in the recipie abovy there is a mixup. You stated 3 table spoons (3 envelopes )of unflavored gelatin. Which one is correct?
Thank you
Each envelope of Knox gelatin is about a tablespoon. So if you are using the gelatin that comes in envelopes (http://www.amazon.com/Knox-Gelatine-Unflavored-Count-Ounce/dp/B00BCMU7T4), its 3 envelopes or if you are using the bulk powder that comes in a canister (http://www.amazon.com/Knox-Unflavored-Gelatin-1-lb/dp/B001UOW7D8), then its 3 tablespoons.
Good luck and thanks!
Victoria
I am not understanding the use of the water- with the coconut milk and rum, is that not sufficient enough to mix in with the gelatin? just curious.
Also, when we make coquito, we use Capt.Morgan spiced rum instead of Bacardi… amazing flavor!
can I use pre made coquito mix with the gelatin
Yes. I have never used it but I would use 4 cups of it in place of all the ingredients except the rum. Pour it into a saucepan and sprinkle the gelatin over it to absorb the liquid and then bring to as boil while whisking.
Good luck and enjoy!
Victoria I found this receipt recently j wanna know what is all spices mean…and do you have a tutorial video or photos to follow because I’m kind of confused and wanna make this but don’t want to mess up. Thanks for your time and sharing I appreciate it hope you answer soon..😬
“Allspice” is the name of a spice. You can buy it at most grocery stores. https://www.thespruceeats.com/what-is-allspice-p2-995556
Hello! If I leave the rum out will the other ingredients stay at the same quantities?
Yes, for this one you can leave the rum out or replace it with water and it will still work. Enjoy!